Best Heart Cookie Cutter Set

What are the best heart cookie cutter sets?

If you want to say “I love you” for breakfast or in cookies, a set of heart-shaped cookie cutters are the best way to do it. These kitchen utensils can help you show your darling how you feel without saying a word, every day of the year.

If you’re looking for a simple heart cookie cutter set that’s versatile and easy to use, the Fasaka Cookie Cutters for Valentine’s Day are your best bet.

What to know before buying a set of heart-shaped cookie cutters


While many people think of a traditional metal cookie cutter, there are other options when it comes to materials. Metal cookie cutters are very versatile, create crisp detail, and can be used for both hot and cold applications, but you might prefer a different one, depending on what you’re cooking.

Look for cookie cutters in:

  • Plastic: Lightweight and easy to use and clean
  • Silicone: Safe at high temperature and easy to clean
  • Drink: Traditional and pleasant to work with, but difficult to clean

cookie cutter type

Heart cookie cutter sets are available in more than just a cut, although this is the most popular and common variety. Also consider these three types.

  • Stamps: Stamp cookie cutters focus less on the shape and more on the pattern on the surface of the cookie.
  • Molds: Molds are similar to stamps, but instead of pressing the stamp into the cookie, you press the cookie into the mold.
  • 3D: If you’ve always wanted to play with your food, a 3D cookie cutter is for you. These allow you to create different shapes and then build a 3D structure with them. They can get really messy and intricate, but they can also be fun to use and decorate with kids.

How do you want to use them

Cookie cutters aren’t just for cookies. Some people also use cookie cutters to make pancakes and shaped eggs. If you want a more versatile tool that can be used for more than cookies, you’ll need a cookie cutter that can handle it.

What to Look for in a Quality Heart Cookie Cutter Set

Quality build

Regardless of the material, your cookie cutters should be well made and durable. All handles or handles should be securely attached and the seams should not interfere with the shape or design of the cookie.

different sizes

Sometimes you want a big cookie, and sometimes a small treat is more appropriate. Look for a set of heart-shaped cookie cutters with different sizes of cookie cutters. They are also great when baking cookies, eggs or pancakes for different sized appetites.

Anti adhesive

Non-stick surfaces mean your cookies release evenly after being pressed, stamped, molded or cut. Some materials like silicone are naturally nonstick, but metal and plastic cookie cutters may need a nonstick treatment to release cookie dough easily.

Handles or handles

The last thing you want when creating an elaborate design in your cookie is to mess it up by pressing a finger in the middle of it to release it from the cookie cutter. Look for handles or grips to easily remove cookie dough.

How much you can expect to spend on a set of heart-shaped cookie cutters

A set of heart-shaped cookie cutters can be a remarkably affordable treat for your sweetheart. Expect to spend $5-40 for a set, depending on the variety of knives, material, and accessories included.

Heart Cookie Cutter Set FAQ

If the cookie cutters aren’t non-stick, how do you make sure your cookies release easily?

A. To make the cookies come off easily, take the time to prepare the cookie cutters. Some bakers like to use nonstick cooking spray, while others thoroughly butter and flour every nook and cranny of cookie stamps, cutouts, and pans. Both methods work well.

What can you use heart cookie cutters for?

A. In addition to cutting out cookies, heart-shaped cookie cutters have other culinary uses, including:

  • Squeeze or cut fondant
  • Stamp a sweet message on a decorated cake
  • Cut out sandwiches
  • Make morning pancakes
  • Cut cookies
  • Serve heart-shaped rice or pasta for dinner
  • Cut ice shapes
  • Make rubber stamps

What is the best set of heart-shaped cookie cutters to buy?

Top Heart cookie cutter set

Fasaka Cookie Cutters for Valentine’s Day

What do you want to know: The whole family can safely use this set of three hearts.

What you will love: The thick stainless steel cookie cutters have a bright red PVC coating on the top edges for added safety and ease of use. This set of three cookie cutters makes cookies from just over 3 inches to just under 2 inches. They release dough easily, and the larger size also works for pancakes.

What you should consider: The seam where the cookie cutter is assembled sometimes creates a crease in the cookie.

Or buy: Sold by Amazon

Set of heart-shaped cookie cutters for money

Wadngxm Heart Cookie Cutter Set

Wadngxm Heart Cookie Cutter Set

What do you want to know: This set of six cookie cutters can hold cookies, biscuits, pancakes and eggs.

What you will love: They are made of stainless steel and are available in six sizes (from almost 4 inches to almost 2 inches). They have sharp edges for easy cutting and can handle pasta up to 1 inch thick. The top of the cutter (where you press) is laminated metal for comfort and safety.

What you should consider: They’re not as sturdy as some other options, but they’re an affordable starting point.

Or buy: Sold by Amazon

Worth checking out

DW Rogers Valentines Day Candy Hearts Cookie Cutter and Stamp Set

DW Rogers Valentine’s Day Candy Hearts Cookie Cutter and Stamp Set

What do you want to know: It’s a good choice if you want to try stamp and cut cookies.

What you will love: The set includes four stamps and a cutout. Pads fit inside the cutout for easier use. The color of these will vary, but they are all made from food safe plastic.

What you should consider: You can’t use them for heated applications (they will melt), and some users have found that the die-cut can’t handle hard dough.

Or buy: Sold by Amazon

Register here to receive the weekly BestReviews newsletter for helpful tips on new products and great deals.

Suzannah Kolbeck written for BestReviews. BestReviews has helped millions of consumers simplify their buying decisions, saving them time and money.

Copyright 2022 BestReviews, a Nexstar company. All rights reserved.

Comments are closed.